2026 Hong Kong Arbitration Week

The mahjong of arbitration: Insights from the tribunal’s perspective

JSM’s fireside chat held on 23 October, brought together a distinguished panel for a lively discussion on arbitration through the lens of mahjong.
Learn more
Thomson Reuters ALB Hong Kong Law Awards 2026/27

JSM named Hong Kong Law Firm of the Year

The Firm was recognised with five awards, including Hong Kong Law Firm of the Year. This represents JSM's 12th win in the category over the last 25 years.
Learn more
JSM Accelerate CPD Series

From innovation to accountability

The full-day programme featured a distinguished speaker line-up, bringing together representatives from Mandiant (part of Google Cloud), Cathay, ALITA, LITE Lab@HKU, Microsoft and the Bar.
Learn more
Appointments

Johnson Stokes & Master appoints new Senior Partner

Geoffrey Chan succeeds Terence Tung who served in the role for ten years.
Learn more
Innovation

Collaborating with Microsoft to advance governance-first AI in legal services

Copilot agent developed for Microsoft to support high-volume employment advisory work.
Learn more
1 2 3 4 5
Introducing JSM

Homegrown.
Global outlook.

Our story is more than 160 years old. It is a story that demonstrates the resilience, spirit and strength the people of Hong Kong are renowned for, as our city grew from the small provincial port in Southern China to become the leading global financial and legal centre that it is today.

When the world has changed so has our firm – always taking the initiative to find the best course through unchartered territory for our clients, the community and our people.

View more
Introducing Johnson Stokes & Master (JSM)

Our story is more than 160 years old. It is a story that demonstrates the resilience, spirit and strength the people of Hong Kong are renowned for, as our city grew from the small provincial port in Southern China to become the leading global financial and legal centre that it is today.

When the world has changed so has our firm – always taking the initiative to find the best course through unchartered territory for our clients, the community and our people.

View more
Who we are

Established in 1863.

Reinvented in 2024.

Insights

Latest publications

An employee sets up a competing business, resigns and takes one of your key customers with them. This is not an unheard-of scenario. But what can an employer do about it? This was the very issue before the Court of First Instance in N.P. King (Hong Kong) Limited and another v Lam Wing Lam and another [2026] HKCFI 5167. Facts The defendant employee (the “Employee”) was a sourcing engineer responsible for the employer’s (the “Company”) business with a major customer (the “Key Customer”) and various Chinese Mainland suppliers. His contract of employment contained confidentiality obligations (which applied during employment and for two years after termination) and 12-month post-termination non-solicitation and non-competition restrictions (PTRs). While still employed, the Employee set up a new company and entered into an agreement with the Key Customer (the “Relevant Agreement”) for his new company to provide sourcing and other services directly to the Key Customer once his employment with the Company ended. Those services substantially overlapped with those provided by the Company. The Employee resigned the following day. Shortly afterwards, the Key Customer gave notice to terminate its agreement with the Company. The Company sued the Employee for breach of his implied duty of fidelity, fiduciary duties, confidentiality obligations and PTRs. The decision 1. Did the Employee breach his implied duty of fidelity? Yes. An employee owes an implied duty of good faith and fidelity during employment. This includes, among other things, a duty not to participate in a competing business or persuade the employer’s customers to move their business away from the employer. On the evidence, the court held that the Employee had gone beyond mere preparation by entering into the agreement with the Key Customer while still employed. In doing so, the Employee had taken a “substantive step” (rather than merely a “preparatory step”) which was bound to result in the appropriation of the Company’s business with the Key Customer. The Employee had therefore breached his implied duty of fidelity. The court stressed that it did not matter whether the Key Customer had initiated negotiations leading to the Relevant Agreement. The Employee’s duty of fidelity did not permit him to participate in a business competing with the Company while still employed. The court awarded HK$227,180.10 in damages for the Company’s loss of profits arising from the Employee’s breach of his duty of fidelity. 2. Did the Employee owe fiduciary duties? No. In determining whether an employee owes fiduciary duties to the employer, the court would consider all the circumstances including specific contractual obligations to determine whether the employee has undertaken to act solely in the employer’s interest in exercising a power or discretion that places the employer in a position of “vulnerability”. Although the court accepted that the Employee had been assigned in charge of all matters relating to transactions involving the Key Customer, the Company failed to plead (or explain in evidence) what power or discretion the Employee had in relation to those transactions. The court therefore held that the Company failed to establish that the Employee owed fiduciary duties. 3. Did the confidentiality claims succeed? No. The Company relied on the Employee’s implied duty not to disclose any confidential information that came to his knowledge during his employment – together with an express contractual confidentiality obligation, which purported to continue for two years after termination. The Company claimed that the Employee had misused the “Confidential information” (as defined in his contract of employment) in operating a competing business, including by distributing price lists and quotes to customers or potential customers. Breach of confidence To establish a breach of confidence, the court explained that the information must have the necessary quality of confidence, have been imparted in circumstances giving rise to an obligation of confidence and have been used without authorisation to the detriment of the person who provided it. The court also emphasised that information alleged to be confidential must be identified with sufficient precision, with particulars demonstrating that the information is confidential in character. However, the court found that the Company’s pleadings were unclear as to what information it alleged was confidential. It was only during cross-examination that the Company confirmed that it relied on its pricing and customer information. Even then, the Company failed to plead why such information was confidential. The court therefore held that the relevant information lacked the necessary quality of confidence. Contractual confidentiality obligation In relation to the contractual confidentiality obligation, the court explained that an employee cannot generally be restrained from using information after termination unless it amounts to a trade secret. As the information in question did not have the necessary quality of confidence, the contractual confidentiality claim also failed. 4. Did the Employee breach the PTRs? Yes. The Employee did not dispute the validity of the non-solicitation restriction, although it is unclear from the judgment whether the same applied to the non-competition restriction. On the evidence, the court found that the Employee had circulated price lists for products which competed with the Company’s products and had approached the Company’s customers about potential business. The court rejected the Employee’s argument that the products targeted a different market segment, finding that they remained sufficiently similar to be competitive. The court therefore held that the Employee was in breach of the non-solicitation and non-competition restrictions. However, there was no evidence of any actual loss or loss of a chance arising from those breaches. The court therefore awarded nominal damages of HK$5,000. Key takeaways Build different layers of protection. There is no single route for protecting an employer when an employee leaves to compete. Protection may come from the implied duty of fidelity, express confidentiality obligations, post-termination restrictions and, in appropriate cases, fiduciary duties. Employers should carefully draft and regularly review their employment contracts to ensure that the protections are tailored to the employee’s role and the legitimate business interests they are intended to protect. Act quickly when “preparatory steps” start to cross the line. If there are signs that a departing employee has gone beyond mere preparation and is already securing customers or competing while still employed, investigate promptly, preserve the evidence and consider what action is needed to protect the business. Seek legal advice if there is any doubt. Be precise about what is confidential. Not all information belonging to an employer will be protected after employment ends, even if the employment contract describes it as “confidential information”. Employers should clearly identify the “confidential information” they seek to protect and be able to explain what makes it confidential. The judgment is available here.
Legal updates 19 November 2026
Legal updates 12 November 2026
Serving court documents across the Hong Kong–Chinese Mainland boundary is a common procedural hurdle in civil proceedings. From 30 March 2027, a new mutual-service arrangement will replace the current framework that has operated for over 27 years, introducing additional ways to progress cross-boundary disputes. The new Arrangement on Mutual Service of Judicial Documents in Civil and Commercial Proceedings between the Chinese Mainland and the Hong Kong Special Administrative Region (New Arrangement)11 was signed on 20 April 2026 by the Supreme People’s Court and the Hong Kong SAR government To implement the New Arrangement, three pieces of subsidiary legislation were made on 12 October 2026 and gazetted on 16 October 2026: Rules of the High Court (Amendment) (No. 2) Rules 202622 Rules of the District Court (Amendment) (No. 2) Rules 202633 Matrimonial Causes (Amendment) Rules 202644 Need for enhanced mechanism Under Article 95 of the Basic Law, the Hong Kong SAR may, through consultations and in accordance with law, maintain juridical relations with the judicial organs of other parts of the country, and they may render assistance to each other. The original arrangement for Mutual Service of Judicial Documents in Civil and Commercial Proceedings between the Chinese Mainland and Hong Kong courts (Existing Arrangement)55 was concluded between Hong Kong and the Chinese Mainland in January 1999. Over the past 27 years since the Existing Arrangement was implemented, the volume of cross boundary service requests has surged, but parties have encountered persistent practical obstacles in effecting successful service. Common reasons for failure to effect service include problems with the recipient’s address and unknown whereabouts66. Over the years, many legal practitioners have had the unpleasant experience of spending months waiting for service to be effected, only to receive a notification saying service was unsuccessful because the recipient was not found at the given address, or no one answered the door. Yet there was no clear answer as to what the plaintiff could do to make another attempt. In cases where the plaintiff later discovered additional addresses or just requested the authority to make another attempt at the same address, the process would drag on for another lengthy period, only for the plaintiff to find itself back to where it was a few months ago, and by then the validity of the writ had probably expired. It is therefore natural for the Legislature of Hong Kong to observe that, where service cannot be effected through the Existing Arrangement, parties often cannot proceed with their cases and their legitimate rights and interests are affected . Against this context, the New Arrangement was introduced to add options and clearer operational features so that cross boundary disputes can move forward more predictably. How the new framework will operate The amendments to the Rules of the High Court (RHC) and Rules of the District Court (RDC) introduce the New Arrangement into Order 11, which governs service outside Hong Kong. The revised rule 5A identifies the permitted service routes, while the new rules 5B-5F prescribe their operation. The new rule 5G contains supplementary provisions, including provisions dealing with cases where the prescribed evidence of receipt is unavailable, translation requirements and the applicable date of service where more than one method is used. Significantly, the amendments move away from reliance on court-to-court entrustment as the principal mechanism for service in the Chinese Mainland and introduce a broader range of service channels. Service through the judicial authorities remains available, but parties will also be able to effect service by post, electronic means or through designated bodies such as law firms. In appropriate circumstances, service by public announcement is also available as a court-directed alternative. The reform also extends to matrimonial proceedings. Under the amended rule 109 of the Matrimonial Causes Rules, any document in matrimonial proceedings may be served outside Hong Kong in accordance with Order 11, rules 5, 5A and 6 of the RHC, as if the document were a writ. The additional modes of service available for service in the Chinese Mainland therefore apply equally in the matrimonial context. Five methods for service in the Chinese Mainland under the New Arrangement Under the amended Order 11, a writ in civil proceedings may be served on a person in the Chinese Mainland by one or more of five prescribed methods. Different methods may be effected in parallel. 1. Service through Chinese Mainland judicial authorities The new rule 5B retains the court-to-court service mechanism. The plaintiff must lodge a request in the registry, together with the prescribed sealed copies of the writ, any required sealed order granting leave to serve out of the jurisdiction, and a suitably modified Form 14 for acknowledgement of service. The request must identify the recipient and address, describe the proceedings and indicate any preferred method of service. The registrar will transmit the documents to the relevant Chinese Mainland judicial authorities to effect service. The new rule also expressly permits the registrar to transmit the documents to the relevant Chinese Mainland judicial authorities electronically. A writ transmitted electronically in this manner has the same legal effect as a sealed copy. 2. Service by post The new rule 5C permits the plaintiff to serve the documents by post from Hong Kong. The prescribed package comprises the sealed writ, any required order granting leave to serve out of the jurisdiction, a suitably modified Form 14 for acknowledgement of service, and the new Form 15B for receipt of service. The date of service is ordinarily the date on which the recipient signs the Form 15B or the postal proof of receipt. Where both documents are signed, the signature date on the postal proof prevails. Accordingly, a recipient-signed postal proof may establish service notwithstanding that the Form 15B has not been returned. Where neither signed document is available, the rules provide a separate mechanism under rule 5G, to be discussed below. 3. Service by electronic transmission The new rule 5D provides for electronic service where the recipient has given a non-verbal notice consenting to accept service electronically and designating an electronic address. A recipient who has not given such prior consent may nevertheless be taken to have consented by acknowledging receipt, participating in the proceedings, providing an electronic service address in specified court documents or otherwise submitting to the court’s jurisdiction. The prescribed documents must be transmitted in a manner that enables receipt to be ascertained and complies with the relevant practice directions. Subject to the applicable requirements, the transmission record, together with the absence of a failed-delivery notification, constitutes the prescribed evidence of electronic service unless the contrary is shown. The date of service is deemed to be the seventh day after transmission unless proven to the contrary. 4. Service through designated bodies The new rule 5E introduces a route for personal service through designated bodies in the Chinese Mainland. Under this route, the plaintiff may instruct a Chinese Mainland law firm or notarial institution to deliver the relevant court documents personally to the recipient. The documents must include the new Form 15B for receipt of service, which the recipient is asked to sign upon receipt. Service is ordinarily treated as effected on the date on which the recipient signs Form 15B. 5. Service by public announcement The new rule 5F provides a fallback method where the court is satisfied that service by any of the other four methods is impracticable. The plaintiff may apply for an order permitting service by public announcement, supported by an affidavit setting out the relevant circumstances, as well as a draft of the proposed announcement. Once the order is made, the plaintiff must lodge with the registry a prescribed request identifying the recipient by full name and address and describing the nature of the proceedings, together with any required sealed order granting leave to serve out of the jurisdiction. The registrar will then request the Chinese Mainland judicial authorities to arrange for the public announcement. Service is deemed to have been effected on the 60th day after the announcement. Provisions for unavailable proof of receipt The new rule 5G contains supplementary provisions governing service under the new framework. Importantly, it addresses circumstances in which the prescribed proof of receipt is unavailable. Where the required receipt does not exist, the rules allow the court to consider other evidence relevant to whether and when the writ came to the recipient’s knowledge. The absence of the prescribed receipt does not therefore necessarily mean that service cannot be established. Rule 5G also addresses the date of service where a writ was duly served by more than one method. In that situation, the earliest date on which service is duly effected applies. Key takeaway The expanded and clarified service options under the New Arrangement are long overdue and will be welcomed by practitioners. They are expected to reduce procedural uncertainty and delay in cross boundary disputes. For businesses operating across Hong Kong and the Chinese Mainland, the New Arrangement is likely to facilitate more reliable litigation planning, clearer assessment of dispute timelines, and reduced scope for tactical delay arising from service difficulties. Taken together with broader developments in cross boundary judicial cooperation, the New Arrangement reinforces Hong Kong’s position as a forum capable of handling disputes with Chinese Mainland elements.
Articles 4 November 2026
Partners TL Lim and Jason Leung, along with legal assistant Ryan Choy wrote an article for The Bulletin, the HKGCC’s monthly magazine, about the growing cybersecurity risks posed by AI. The article highlights how increasingly autonomous AI agents can identify vulnerabilities, coordinate attacks and operate across multiple systems with limited human intervention. For Hong Kong businesses, it argues that AI-related cybersecurity risk should now be treated as a board-level governance issue, with particular attention given to AI-driven attacks and shadow AI within organisations. It recommends stronger accountability, vendor oversight, patching and incident-response practices, alongside clear policies governing employees’ use of AI tools.
People

Find a lawyer

Learn more about our lawyers and the work they do for clients in Hong Kong, across the region and globally.
View all
Find a JSM lawyer

Responsible business

DE&I

Respecting, supporting and empowering our people at work and in the community.
View more

Social impact

Advancing sustainability and empowering communities for a better future.
View more

Pro bono

Legal service as a catalyst for community change.
View more
Explore

Careers

At Johnson Stokes & Master, we provide a pathway for your professional growth and advancement. With our deep-rooted and extensive history, we invite you to explore current opportunities to join us, thrive in a supportive environment, and make a meaningful impact for our clients.
View more
JSM Careers

Please scan the QR code and follow us on WeChat

Wechat ID: JSM_Legal
JSM WeChat QR code