Legal updates 19 November 2026

Crossing the line before resigning: Hong Kong court finds employee in breach of duty of fidelity

Author(s): Hong Tran , Liuh Jang Kwok

An employee sets up a competing business, resigns and takes one of your key customers with them. This is not an unheard-of scenario. But what can an employer do about it?

This was the very issue before the Court of First Instance in N.P. King (Hong Kong) Limited and another v Lam Wing Lam and another [2026] HKCFI 5167.

Facts

The defendant employee (the “Employee”) was a sourcing engineer responsible for the employer’s (the “Company”) business with a major customer (the “Key Customer”) and various Chinese Mainland suppliers.

His contract of employment contained confidentiality obligations (which applied during employment and for two years after termination) and 12-month post-termination non-solicitation and non-competition restrictions (PTRs).

While still employed, the Employee set up a new company and entered into an agreement with the Key Customer (the “Relevant Agreement”) for his new company to provide sourcing and other services directly to the Key Customer once his employment with the Company ended. Those services substantially overlapped with those provided by the Company.

The Employee resigned the following day. Shortly afterwards, the Key Customer gave notice to terminate its agreement with the Company.

The Company sued the Employee for breach of his implied duty of fidelity, fiduciary duties, confidentiality obligations and PTRs.

The decision

1. Did the Employee breach his implied duty of fidelity? Yes.

An employee owes an implied duty of good faith and fidelity during employment. This includes, among other things, a duty not to participate in a competing business or persuade the employer’s customers to move their business away from the employer.

On the evidence, the court held that the Employee had gone beyond mere preparation by entering into the agreement with the Key Customer while still employed.

In doing so, the Employee had taken a “substantive step” (rather than merely a “preparatory step”) which was bound to result in the appropriation of the Company’s business with the Key Customer. The Employee had therefore breached his implied duty of fidelity.

The court stressed that it did not matter whether the Key Customer had initiated negotiations leading to the Relevant Agreement. The Employee’s duty of fidelity did not permit him to participate in a business competing with the Company while still employed.

The court awarded HK$227,180.10 in damages for the Company’s loss of profits arising from the Employee’s breach of his duty of fidelity.

2. Did the Employee owe fiduciary duties? No.

In determining whether an employee owes fiduciary duties to the employer, the court would consider all the circumstances including specific contractual obligations to determine whether the employee has undertaken to act solely in the employer’s interest in exercising a power or discretion that places the employer in a position of “vulnerability”.

Although the court accepted that the Employee had been assigned in charge of all matters relating to transactions involving the Key Customer, the Company failed to plead (or explain in evidence) what power or discretion the Employee had in relation to those transactions.

The court therefore held that the Company failed to establish that the Employee owed fiduciary duties.

3. Did the confidentiality claims succeed? No.

The Company relied on the Employee’s implied duty not to disclose any confidential information that came to his knowledge during his employment – together with an express contractual confidentiality obligation, which purported to continue for two years after termination.

The Company claimed that the Employee had misused the “Confidential information” (as defined in his contract of employment) in operating a competing business, including by distributing price lists and quotes to customers or potential customers.

Breach of confidence

To establish a breach of confidence, the court explained that the information must have the necessary quality of confidence, have been imparted in circumstances giving rise to an obligation of confidence and have been used without authorisation to the detriment of the person who provided it.

The court also emphasised that information alleged to be confidential must be identified with sufficient precision, with particulars demonstrating that the information is confidential in character.

However, the court found that the Company’s pleadings were unclear as to what information it alleged was confidential. It was only during cross-examination that the Company confirmed that it relied on its pricing and customer information. Even then, the Company failed to plead why such information was confidential.

The court therefore held that the relevant information lacked the necessary quality of confidence.

Contractual confidentiality obligation

In relation to the contractual confidentiality obligation, the court explained that an employee cannot generally be restrained from using information after termination unless it amounts to a trade secret. As the information in question did not have the necessary quality of confidence, the contractual confidentiality claim also failed.

4. Did the Employee breach the PTRs? Yes.

The Employee did not dispute the validity of the non-solicitation restriction, although it is unclear from the judgment whether the same applied to the non-competition restriction.

On the evidence, the court found that the Employee had circulated price lists for products which competed with the Company’s products and had approached the Company’s customers about potential business.

The court rejected the Employee’s argument that the products targeted a different market segment, finding that they remained sufficiently similar to be competitive. The court therefore held that the Employee was in breach of the non-solicitation and non-competition restrictions.

However, there was no evidence of any actual loss or loss of a chance arising from those breaches. The court therefore awarded nominal damages of HK$5,000.

Key takeaways

  • Build different layers of protection. There is no single route for protecting an employer when an employee leaves to compete. Protection may come from the implied duty of fidelity, express confidentiality obligations, post-termination restrictions and, in appropriate cases, fiduciary duties. Employers should carefully draft and regularly review their employment contracts to ensure that the protections are tailored to the employee’s role and the legitimate business interests they are intended to protect.
  • Act quickly when “preparatory steps” start to cross the line. If there are signs that a departing employee has gone beyond mere preparation and is already securing customers or competing while still employed, investigate promptly, preserve the evidence and consider what action is needed to protect the business. Seek legal advice if there is any doubt.
  • Be precise about what is confidential. Not all information belonging to an employer will be protected after employment ends, even if the employment contract describes it as “confidential information”. Employers should clearly identify the “confidential information” they seek to protect and be able to explain what makes it confidential.

The judgment is available here.

Subscribe

Follow our insights

Sign up for regular updates covering the latest news, regulations and case law relevant to your business.
View more
Johnson Stokes & Master - Sign up for JSM's regular updates covering the latest news, regulations and case law relevant to your business

Please scan the QR code and follow us on WeChat

Wechat ID: JSM_Legal
JSM WeChat QR code